Tooky Mills Pub

Something smelled delicious and I asked our awesome waitress to find out what the goodness was. She found the customer next to us had shrimp scampi. I don’t like shrimp. “We can make chicken scampi” ok!!! Me- “Can you add veggies?” W- “yes!”….OMG it was so good! Before that we had pork dumplings with this yummy sauce. And we had the best brownie sundae I ever had 😊

First timer here at Tooky Mills Pub! I dined mid-day just after lunch rush was over. The place was empty with only 2 souls at the bar. When I walked in, I was greeted by the bartender who placed me at a table in the next room. Brenda came right out and gave me some water and took my food request. I ordered the baked haddock with mashed potatoes and a ceasar Salad. My food all came out at once, which was kinda strange, as salad would typically come first. Regardless, the food was absolutely amazing and I couldn't get enough of it! The taste in their food was heavenly. That melt in your mouth breaded baked haddock was so good that im still thinking about it. Their potatoes were so rich and creamy that paired perfectly with their flavourful brown gravy. Their ceasar dressing is thick and creamy that sticks to every piece of green. 10 out of 10 for flavor and freshness. Overall, I thought the service was okay. They felt more like a bar type atmosphere and I didnt really get the super friendly server / guest experience I would typically get at most small sit down restaurants. The atmosphere was nice and clean. The food was really something special to write about and absolutely worth the price I paid. If you are in the area stop by and try their food, you won't regret it!

Wow.. What a great place, Very cozy place. The service was great,super friendly, and always smiling. We had a party of six,me and my wife and I were the newbies to this place. My wife had the steak tips and butternut squash. The portions were a good size and worth the price. I had the baked haddock and loaded mashed potatoes. The fish was cooked just right, and the potatoes.... what can I say,I wish I had some more right now. If you're in the area, stop in. You'll be glad you did!

Hands down the best food in the Hillsborough area. This place has the kind of cozy tavern atmosphere that you read about. The kitchen is clean, the service is good and the food is excellent. Dishes that the owner perfected years ago and continues to serve up consistently ever since. If you're looking for great homemade tasting comfort food then this place is it..

My fiancé and I are vacationing in the area and decided upon this restaurant after flipping a coin. Thankful it landed on heads! But seriously, it was a really cool atmosphere and the food was incredible. Homemade basil oregano bread, delicious steak tips and chicken, and the dessert selection was out of this world. The prices were also very reasonable. I loved that the owners / managers, whichever they were, seemed to enjoy the end of their shift by chatting with some of the local regulars. The woman who baked the bread and probably did much more (Wendy) was sitting next to us at the bar so I had an opportunity to thank her for the quality of the food. Buffalo chicken sandwich was the best I’ve had in a long time, and don’t forget to ask about the desserts! The raspberry crème brûlée cheesecake was phenomenal. We will be back the next time we are in town.

Something smelled delicious and I asked our awesome waitress to find out what the goodness was. She found the customer next to us had shrimp scampi. I don’t like shrimp. “We can make chicken scampi” ok!!! Me- “Can you add veggies?” W- “yes!”….OMG it was so good! Before that we had pork dumplings with this yummy sauce. And we had the best brownie sundae I ever had 😊